Killing Taylor Shaw
About 25 years before the show's events, Bill accidentally killed Taylor and buried her body in an area of the woods a select few know.
He was the main suspect to Taylor's disappearance and murder. Though he never confessed, and criminal charges were dropped due to lack of evidence and the was police unable to find the corpse.
However, Bill was shunned by the town and his children as many believed he was indeed guilty. His son, Kurt, particularly held the most animosity and hatred towards him, which persisted into adulthood.
#5 Split the Law
#6 Cede Your Soul
#8 Persecute Envoys
#12 Scientists Hollow Fortune
#16 Any Wounded Thief
#17 Mans Telepathic Loyal Lookouts
#18 One Begets Technique
#19 In the Comet of Us
#22 If Love a Rebel, Death Will Render